> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.421.news/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Dungeons & Dragons: The Art of Making Up Stories with Friends
- URL: https://www.421.news/en/dungeons-dragons-roleplay/
- Published: 2026-11-22T11:01:20.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-22T11:15:53.000Z
- Description: Telling stories out loud and rolling dice. The magic of D&D, the role-playing game that keeps friendships alive.
- Author: Rodrigo Illarraga
- Tags: games, #en

Almost every weekend, when work and travel (which are sometimes one and the same) allow it, five friends and I sneak off for a couple of hours. [Soccer](https://www.421.news/en/futcon-2026-soccer/), yoga or the gym are for after work; on Saturday or Sunday, when we have a little more time, we do our part to keep the friendship (more) alive. I think within 30 minutes, after the usual delays and while we catch up, we all arrive at a town not far from the coast, half-forgotten and far from everything. It doesn't have many people and it's been in open decline for decades: only a few buildings remain from what, the locals tell us, was a glorious past of which there's little real record. I have to admit I never imagined coming out this way, but seeing each other this often, closer to 40 than to 30, is truly a [privilege](https://www.421.news/en/cooperative-gaming-loneliness-en/). And honestly, we've grown fond of the town and its surroundings, with its hills and its forests.

Phandalin lies on the Sword Coast, some 60 kilometers from the city of Neverwinter. And we're scattered across the world, five friends in four different time zones, up to six hours apart (one day it was 12 hours) and 15,000 kilometers. Thank you, [Dungeons & Dragons](https://www.421.news/en/dungeons-and-dragons-history-and-legacy/); thank you, Forgotten Realms.

Closeness is a technology that sometimes goes unnoticed. When it doesn't, it gets associated with things that are really just possibilities for closeness: Discord, Roll20, WhatsApp are incredible tools but, at the end of the day, mere tools. The real magic of technology is, as always, human: the will to use the available means toward the ends we want. The truth is that the first technology of closeness is [imagination](https://www.421.news/en/cognitive-sovereignty-an-introduction-to-psychic-autonomy/): it's imagination that lets us get together to roleplay across an assembly of devices and screens, it's what lets us create a complex, sprawling world, and characters with their dreams, anxieties, desires and passions.

> It's imagination that lets us get together to roleplay across an assembly of devices and screens, it's what lets us create a complex, sprawling world.

It's hard to explain what a [role-playing game](https://www.421.news/en/apocalypse-games-rol-board-philosophy-en/) is. The closest thing I can think of is a novel written out loud without knowing what happens next. There's someone running it (the GM, DM, narrator, call it what you like) who takes charge of the entire world: describes the town, moves the people who live there, decides whether behind the door there's a staircase or an ambush. The rest of us each play a character: a name, a past, desires, dreams, aspirations and a list of numbers that say how strong, how fast and how persuasive they are, among many other things. The mathematization of life. You say what your character does, the one running the game says whether that's easy, hard or impossible, and when in doubt you roll a twenty-sided die: you add the character's skill to the result and that's how we find out whether they climbed the wall or fell and broke their back (that's where we're alike: our characters probably have a herniated disc or two as well). Nothing more than that: a handful of rules to distribute uncertainty and keep any one person from deciding alone how the scene ends, and three hours of grown adults making up a story out loud.

> Perception check. 20, critical success. Suddenly, you notice a voice you hadn't heard before, faint, distant. You strain your ears and can hear it better.

Phandalin is written in layers. For my friends, the town is what they can see when they arrive: an inn, a miners' exchange, an apple orchard, the ruins of an old manor on a hill. For me, as DM, it's quite a bit bigger. Every [building](https://www.421.news/en/shadow-colossus-videogames-cult-en/) has a past, every resident knows some things and is ignorant of others, has affections, loyalties, fears and problems that keep moving forward even when the players look the other way. Daran, the old drow who now grows apples, hints at an adventuring past he says little about. Halia, the woman who runs the miners' exchange, always seems to know a bit more than she should. 

During the week I write those stories, go over maps, calculate distances, decide what changed while the characters were away and try to remember who trusts them, who owes them a favor and who has reasons to lie to them. Most of that work may never show up directly, and it has the beauty of being an effort completely stripped of any mercantile or capitalist sense of “value.” Being a DM is full of writing and thinking up stories that will never be told, treasures they'll never find, or castles they'll decide not to visit because, let's be honest, sometimes the plans of some of this fantasy world's inhabitants don't survive the incisive analysis of a group of [veteran roleplayers](https://www.421.news/en/421-collection-dungeons-and-dragons-black-box/) who have seen far too many times how good intentions lead to disaster.

> Making Phandalin means building a place solid enough that my friends can break it, defend it, change it and, with a little luck, feel that in some sense it also exists and belongs to them.

But it would be simplistic to say that creative effort is in vain. It's there so that when my friends do something I hadn't anticipated, the town can respond like a place and not like a set. My job is to give it enough spatial, historical and human consistency that they accept that, for a few hours, Phandalin exists; then I have to hand over control and let them transform it. That's the balance: prepare enough that they can do anything, but not so much that I force them to do what I prepared. Because the main rule is that they have fun, and each of them has fun with something different. Sometimes I spend the whole week imagining conspiracies, creatures and ancient ruins, and the best scene ends up being the halfling Fofo getting escorted out of Daran's house after an unfortunate comment about his family; Bjorn insisting that before saving the world you have to eat and sleep; Enthe secretly accepting help from an unknown intelligence because he believes that way he'll be able to protect his friends, even though he knows they'll never understand; or Lazavhal wondering whether his path really lies in going from adventure to adventure or in staying and putting down roots. Making Phandalin means building a place solid enough that my friends can break it, defend it, change it and, with a little luck, feel that in some sense it also exists and belongs to them.

> *You stop hearing the voice. It seems to have stopped talking. Or maybe you got distracted by the noises around you, you're not quite sure.* 

Sometimes, a handful of times every couple of months, we manage to line up as a group for a [virtual RPG](https://www.421.news/en/argentum-online-en/), Baldur's Gate 3\. I can't go into detail about the Baldur's Gate series right now, a subject I'll save for another time because it's one of the most influential games in history. Let's just say that the first two, from 1998 and 2000 and made by BioWare, tell the story of an orphan raised in a fortress-library (Candlekeep!) who discovers, amid trade conspiracies and murders, that he's one of the children of Bhaal, the god of murder, and that half the Sword Coast wants him dead or wants to use him; the second adds a wizard who kidnaps him to squeeze that divine inheritance out of him like juice from a fruit. 

They were played with a top-down camera, with the Dungeons & Dragons rules running underneath and a group of companions you picked up along the way who fought among themselves. The third one is from 2023, made by Larian (another studio, another generation, other rules), and it's turn-based, like at a table: you move, roll, miss, and only then is it the next person's turn. That's where what interests me comes in: the design anticipated so many different ways of resolving each scene (talking, stealing, pushing someone off a cliff, convincing an enemy to switch sides, setting the floor on fire or covering it in oil so people slip, among so many others) that in some small measure, and only at moments, it resembles the messy freedom of a tabletop session.

For those of us in the habit of playing tabletop RPGs, even on digital platforms, Baldur's Gate 3 doesn't trim back the habit of imagination: it manages to widen the page's [margins](https://www.421.news/en/dark-souls-videogame-tragedy-dignity-human-en/). Something fascinating happens that differs, from everything I understand, from people who only play video games: coordination and min-maxing don't come into play, and the disorderly interactions of a table get replicated. Min-maxing is, more or less, the habit of building a character the way you'd build a formula: you pick the combinations of classes and skills that yield the most, you dump the numbers that don't serve what you have in mind (eloquence, say, if the plan is to solve everything with an axe) and you pump everything that increases damage per turn. Coordination is the same thing applied to the group: one who tanks the hits, another who heals, another who picks locks and disarms traps, each with their assigned role and with the sequence of actions more or less rehearsed before the fight starts. It's a perfectly legitimate way to play, and for a lot of people it's the most fun way to play, like solving a puzzle: the game is a system that can be solved, and solving it well brings a pleasure I understand even if I don't share it. 

It's different for us: we wander around the virtual map as if we were describing the action out loud, with the same imprecision and lack of rigor. We're not trying to beat the game, we're trying to have fun. My heartfelt thanks to the developers at Larian for creating a platform that lets you pull off any imaginable lunacy. The fact that every enemy fallen in battle (hundreds, thousands over the course of the game) can be interrogated using “Speak with Dead” is one of many examples of gorgeous design work.

---

After a couple of hours someone checks the time. For one of us it's probably past midnight, and maybe someone else has to go to work the next day. It always gets late on us, we're always as tired as our characters. HP is dropping, no doubt about it. Within seconds we're back to being six hours and 15,000 kilometers apart. We and our characters are left suspended, waiting for next weekend. But we're also left with the feeling of building something together. A story that is really two: that of our own friendship over the years and that of those adventurers weaving their destiny in Phandalin. Spending three straight hours making up nonsense with the same five people, week after week and with the punctuality of a work obligation, looks less like a pastime and more like a ritual with something sacred about it. 

Maybe I was wrong. Maybe Phandalin does exist.