UBA's New Bachelor's Degree in Complex Systems: How It Was Conceived From the Inside
From Clementina to the new Complex Systems degree, UBA reopens an old question: should it train specialists, or leaders who can see the whole picture?
“Compared with the medieval university, the contemporary University has enormously complicated the professional instruction which the former provided in rudimentary form, and it has added research, while almost entirely dropping the teaching or transmission of culture. This has obviously been an atrocity. (…) This average man is the new barbarian, a laggard behind his own age. (…) This new barbarian is above all the professional, more learned than ever before, but at the same time more uncultured: the engineer, the physician, the lawyer, the scientist.”
José Ortega y Gasset, Mission of the University (1930)
“I saw the Aleph from every point and angle, and in the Aleph I saw the earth and in the earth the Aleph and in the Aleph the earth; I saw my own face and my own bowels; I saw your face; and I felt dizzy and wept, for my eyes had seen that secret and conjectured object whose name is common to all men but which no man has looked upon — the unimaginable universe.”
Jorge Luis Borges, “The Aleph” (1945)
Fifteen years of crossovers
For about fifteen years now I — a political scientist trained in institutional analysis and comparative politics — have been arguing about the university, politics and the world with colleagues and friends from the School of Engineering. Two of the people who have influenced me most intellectually, and with whom I argue the most, are the driving forces behind the new Complex Systems degree we've announced: Federico Carrone and Francisco Strambini. The platform where I'm writing these lines, 421.news, is the product of an ecosystem of reflection, debate and shared work that embodies those intersections between people coming from the social sciences, philosophy and history, and people coming from engineering, applied mathematics and the hard sciences.
The proposal for the Bachelor's Degree in Complex Systems was presented on November 11 at the School of Economics. It still has several institutional steps ahead: the curriculum has to be voted on by the schools taking part in the initiative and then by the Superior Council, and along the way it will be debated to completion and take its final shape. What it has already produced is a spectacular discussion and contribution to the public conversation. Juan Ruocco laid out in these pages the systemic crisis the degree responds to, and Federico Carrone explained the big picture as well as the details of the proposal. This piece aims to add what's missing from that conversation: the view from “inside” the university, that of those of us who have been working on the initiative from within the institution, with an agenda for debate that people who are part of UBA, but think from LambdaClass, have been pushing for years.
This piece aims to add what's missing from that conversation: the view from “inside” the university, that of those of us who have been working on the initiative from within the institution.
It's no coincidence that at the degree's launch, Raúl Bertero, current vice-dean and dean-elect of the School of Engineering, didn't cite a paper to explain the concept behind it. He turned to a professor from the University of Buenos Aires, perhaps the most universal one we've ever had, Jorge Luis Borges: he said the degree was “a kind of Aleph of knowledge.” I'll come back to this idea at the end.
I want to lay out three ideas here about the nature of this experiment we're starting and what it means for UBA, for its history and for its present. The first: the degree arrives at a moment when the mission of the university, and the conception of knowledge that has ruled since modernity, are once again in question. It's the tension between an integral conception of knowledge, which takes us back to the figure of the polymath, and the logic of hyper-specialization that organized the work of universities and official science and technology institutions for decades. The second: why a degree like this matters for UBA, whose mission is to train Argentina's strategic leadership in the most diverse fields — a mission it fulfills not in spite of open access, but thanks to it. The third: what kind of thing this degree is. It's an experimental project in the most scientific sense of the word: a controlled pilot test that allows for specific innovations and is not a break with what we do at UBA. If anything, it's the opposite.
The mission of the university, in question once again
“Science has entered a phase of specialization previously unknown, and this will forever remain the case.”
Max Weber, Science as a Vocation (1917).
Max Weber, one of the most brilliant intellectuals in history and possibly the sharpest analyst of the modern scientist's “spirit,” described the condition of modern science in 1917: “in our time, the truly important and definitive work is always the work of specialists.” For a century that condition organized the work of universities, their schools, their degrees. What artificial intelligence calls into question isn't science: it's that order. When a language model produces the first draft of a specialist's work in minutes, value shifts, as Carrone writes, one layer up: choosing which problem is worth tackling, integrating what different disciplines bring to the table, and owning the result. In other words, precisely what Weber played down in scientific work.
The tension isn't new. In 1930 José Ortega y Gasset formulated it with a precision that feels like it was written this year: “In order to progress, science needed men of science to specialize. Men of science, not science itself. Science is not a specialist. Ipso facto it would cease to be true.” Hence his figure of the “learned ignoramus,” the specialist who “‘knows’ very well his own tiny corner of the universe, but is radically ignorant of all the rest,” and who behaves in everything he doesn't know “not like an ignoramus, but with all the petulance of one who is learned in his own special line.” It's worth reading him carefully: Ortega wasn't against specialization, which he called inescapable for scientific work. He was against a university that had stopped transmitting culture, “the vital system of ideas of each age.” His answer was institutional: “I would make a ‘Faculty’ of Culture the nucleus of the University and of all higher education,” with five disciplines: the physical scheme of the world, the fundamental themes of organic life, history, social life and philosophy [1]. Compare that list with the three modules — condensing the core content of six current CBC subjects — that open the Bachelor's Degree in Complex Systems: mathematical modeling, scientific and computational thinking, economics, institutions and government. We really ought to credit Ortega y Gasset with the copyright.
It's tempting to say the degree goes back to the medieval university, the one of integral knowledge, of the polymath who understood the whole world. Historians advise against nostalgia. Jacques Le Goff shows that the twelfth-century intellectual “regards and feels himself as an artisan, as a man of a trade,” and that in the Bologna of the first universities “each faculty forms a separate corporation.” Universitas was the name of the guild, not of the universality of knowledge. What the Middle Ages did leave us is something else, more modest and more useful: the liberal arts as propaedeutics, a common stretch of training before the faculties. The ideal of the unity of knowledge, on the other hand, is modern. The degree in no way aims for a regression to the Middle Ages: it takes up a modern ideal that practice gradually abandoned.
The degree in no way aims for a regression to the Middle Ages: it takes up a modern ideal that practice gradually abandoned.
Edgar Morin, who is cited in the rationale of the curriculum, gave the problem a name: “hyperspecialization prevents us from seeing the global (which it fragments into parcels) and the essential (which it dissolves).” And he brought back Pascal, who already in the seventeenth century held it “impossible to know the parts without knowing the whole, and to know the whole without knowing the parts in particular.” Herbert Simon, the other name the curriculum invokes, defined a complex system in 1962 as one “made up of a large number of parts that interact in a nonsimple way,” where “the whole is more than the sum of the parts” — not in a metaphysical sense but in the practical sense that inferring the whole from the parts is not trivial. A power grid, health infrastructure, a political system, a market, a city.
The concept of complexity, what's more, has left its mark on this house. In 1969 Oscar Varsavsky, who had founded the Mathematical Economics group at the Exactas Institute of Calculus, wrote that the national characteristic of science is “the great complexity, both intrinsic and in interaction with the environment, displayed by all systems and phenomena on a human scale.” Complexity as an object of study, and as an Argentine problem, has a clear history of more than half a century at UBA.
Training leaders with the doors wide open
“Without which one remains a ‘specialist’ and does not become a ‘leader’ (specialist + politician).”
Antonio Gramsci, Prison Notebooks, Notebook 12 (1932).
The second idea is why a degree like this matters for the University of Buenos Aires. Among its missions, UBA has the task of training Argentina's strategic leadership in the most diverse fields: the State, business, science, culture. And it fulfills that mission in a way that, from the outside, often looks like a contradiction: with open access, meaning tuition-free and with unrestricted admission. It isn't a contradiction. It's a long tradition, and there's theoretical depth and empirical evidence to back it up: it's a model built up starting with the University Reform of 1918, moving through the free tuition instituted by Peronism in 1949 and culminating in the democratic opening with unrestricted admission and the creation of the CBC in 1984 under Alfonsín's normalization. We could read them (à la Huntington) as the three democratizing waves of higher education in Argentina.
Gramsci, from prison, wrote against Gentile's education reform and against the tendency to “spread ever more widely the specialized vocational schools in which the pupil's destiny and future activity are predetermined.” His alternative was a “common basic school of general, humanistic, formative culture,” from which, “through repeated experiences of vocational guidance, one would pass on to one of the specialized schools.” The new intellectual, he said, comes from technique-as-work to technique-as-science and to the humanistic historical conception, without which he stays a specialist and never becomes a leader. And he added something that sounds familiar around here: that school “requires that the State be able to take on the expenses currently borne by the family.” General education before specialization, leaders and not just technicians, and free tuition, all on the same page.
The other path is the French one, and Bourdieu described it mercilessly. The university field “reproduces in its specifically academic logic the structure of the field of power,” with the faculties arranged “between the pole of economic and political power and the pole of cultural prestige.” And the grandes écoles manufacture what he called a state nobility: an elite consecrated by academic credentials, selected through competitive exams and cultural inheritance, with the token admission of a few working-class students that props up the meritocratic illusion. France selects first and consecrates later. UBA opens first and trains later. Juan Carlos Portantiero said it about the 1918 Reform: it was “the greatest ideological school for the advanced sectors of the petty bourgeoisie, the most frequent recruiting ground for the counter-elites that confronted the oligarchies, and from them emerged most of Latin America's civilian leaders.”
France selects first and consecrates later. UBA opens first and trains later.
The inspiration that Carrone, the LambdaClass team and those of us working on this from UBA always had in our sights comes from another experience, and it's worth looking at closely because it says more than people usually tell. In 1920, right after the First World War, when the British Empire had reached its greatest territorial extent but was already showing the cracks of its decline, the University of Oxford created the degree in Philosophy, Politics and Economics (PPE). Its statute defined it as the study of "the structure, and the philosophical, political and economic principles of modern society." They christened it Modern Greats because it came to replace the Greats, the study of classical antiquity reserved for those who knew ancient Greek and Latin, as the training for those who would fill the public offices and civil service of a world that had changed. But PPE had a second, less remembered goal. By eliminating the requirement of knowing ancient Greek, a specialty reserved for the most exclusive private schools, it opened Oxford's best education to those coming from state schools. Its champion, A. D. Lindsay, wanted to broaden the social base of top-tier education. That reform, however, was preceded by nearly two decades of attempts to reform the university and make access to it more inclusive: starting in 1902 there were reform proposals that sought to widen access to the training of Britain's future leaders, and they failed to win institutional victories; Lord George Curzon, elected chancellor of the university in 1907, pushed several reforms that he set down in his Principles and Methods of University Reform, in which widening the university's social intake (to the rising middle classes, workers and women) was one of the main concerns. PPE was one of the offspring of that process. In other words: even Oxford, in order to train leaders capable of understanding a new world, had to break with a deeply restrictive tradition and convince itself that strategic leadership requires open access. That's what PPE was in the context of Oxford. The Bachelor's Degree in Complex Systems takes up that ambition for the present: it adds the natural sciences, computing and artificial intelligence, and it is set within a university where open access is a defining trait.
An experiment, not a rupture
"To the scientific mind, all knowledge is an answer to a question. If there was no question, there can be no scientific knowledge. Nothing is self-evident. Nothing is given. Everything is constructed."
Gaston Bachelard, The Formation of the Scientific Mind (1938)
The third idea is the nature of this degree as a project, and this is where a few clarifications are in order. The Bachelor's Degree in Complex Systems is an experimental project in the most positivist and scientific sense of the word experiment: a controlled experience that allows for trial and error, designed to advance knowledge. It is experimental in its object, in its design and in its teaching. The university has experimental schools, institutes, areas and initiatives: what's new is that this is the first undergraduate degree conceived this way. And from the perspective of those of us who do public policy, that has a name: a pilot program. A pilot program allows for specific innovations, because that's what it's for. It's a controlled setting for testing alternatives within the university's framework, with particular features designed for that purpose.
Let me put it with a concrete example, because it's the one that raises the most questions: admission. The degree begins with an intensive, mandatory introductory preparatory course, which is part of the curriculum and must be passed in full. What that course does is gather and condense the minimum content of subjects from the Ciclo Básico Común (the Common Basic Cycle): Introduction to Scientific Thinking and Computational Thinking, which is one of UBA's newest subjects, created in 2022, and one of the largest university programming-teaching experiences in the region; a synthesis of the principles of Algebra and Calculus; and a combination of Economics, Government Institutions and Introduction to the Study of Society and the State. It's the CBC in intensive format, shaped by the logic of the degree that follows. The idea of a common educational cycle before specialization is the oldest of all the ones this degree takes up. It's in the medieval liberal arts, in Ortega y Gasset's "Faculty of Culture," in Gramsci's unified school, in the "cultural foundation" that rector Risieri Frondizi preached, and in the 1984 resolution that created the CBC. A pilot that condenses that cycle doesn't negate it: it puts it to the test by implementing it another way.
Rolando García, the dean of the School of Exact Sciences who installed Argentina's first scientific computer, the famous Clementina, left behind the rule for not getting confused: "neither does condemning 'excessive specialization' lead, by opposition, to interdisciplinarity, nor is it possible to do without specialists even in interdisciplinary research." Interdisciplinarity, he said, "is a way of working, a certain kind of activity," not a sum of sectoral studies. The same goes for the institution. The degree doesn't replace specialists, or the schools, or common admission. It tries out a different way of working, and puts it under observation. The curriculum includes a course on experimental design and teaches students to define in advance which results will justify expanding, modifying or halting an intervention. That rule applies to the degree itself, too. It's what distinguishes an experiment from an act of faith.
The degree doesn't replace specialists, or the schools, or common admission. It tries out a different way of working, and puts it under observation.
Nor is this the first time UBA has done this. Clementina started running on May 15, 1961, at the Exact Sciences' Institute of Calculus, and was the first scientific computer to operate in Argentina, one that mathematicians, physicists and economists turned to as a tool for their research. That Institute gave rise, in 1963, to the first university computing degree in Argentina, one of the first in Latin America. It was, also, an experiment by the university on itself. It wasn't ended by failure: it was ended by a police baton, on the night of July 29, 1966, when almost the entire Institute of Calculus resigned.
Two years later, Jorge Sabato (physicist and technologist) and Natalio Botana (political scientist and historian) wrote together that development results "from the multiple and coordinated action of three fundamental elements in the development of contemporary societies: the government, the productive structure and the scientific-technological infrastructure." A degree designed between the public university, the State that funds it and an engineering company born in its classrooms is that triangle in action. That's why the experiment is worth doing here. Experiences of restricting higher education in Argentina have been lackluster, anachronistic and a downgrade in terms of quality: the last experience with tuition fees and heavy restrictions was the one imposed by Argentina's last military dictatorship, and UBA suffered it in particular. Many of today's professors and administrators took part in the protests at the end of the dictatorship where the infamous "blue checkbooks" were burned, protests that heralded the last democratizing wave in higher education, which the Alfonsín government represented and the administration of rector Francisco Delich designed and implemented.
The Aleph
Back to Bertero and to Borges. When the dean-elect of Engineering said the degree was "a kind of Aleph of knowledge," he wasn't indulging in a baroque metaphor. He was describing the problem the degree wants to teach people to see: a point from which all the parts can be seen at once, without any of them ceasing to be a part. The passage is well known, but it's worth reading in full, because each of those "I saw"s the narrator lists, in the basement of Carlos Argentino Daneri's house, can be thought of as a discipline:
"Each thing (the glass of the mirror, let's say) was infinite things, because I clearly saw it from every point in the universe. I saw the teeming sea, I saw dawn and dusk, I saw the multitudes of America, I saw a silvery spiderweb at the center of a black pyramid, I saw a broken labyrinth (it was London), I saw endless eyes close by, peering into me as into a mirror, I saw all the mirrors on the planet and none of them reflected me, I saw in a back patio on Soler Street the same tiles I had seen thirty years ago in the entryway of a house in Fray Bentos, I saw clusters of grapes, snow, tobacco, veins of metal, water vapor, I saw convex equatorial deserts and every one of their grains of sand, I saw in Inverness a woman I will never forget, I saw the violent mane of hair, the proud body, I saw a cancer in the breast, I saw a circle of dry earth on a sidewalk where there had once been a tree, I saw a country house in Adrogué, a copy of the first English version of Pliny, Philemon Holland's, I saw at once every letter on every page (as a boy, I used to marvel that the letters in a closed book didn't get mixed up and lost over the course of the night), I saw night and day at the same time, I saw a sunset in Querétaro that seemed to reflect the color of a rose in Bengal, I saw my bedroom with no one in it, I saw in a cabinet in Alkmaar a terrestrial globe between two mirrors that multiplied it endlessly, I saw horses with swirling manes on a beach of the Caspian Sea at dawn, I saw the delicate bone structure of a hand, I saw the survivors of a battle sending postcards, I saw in a shop window in Mirzapur a Spanish deck of cards, I saw the slanting shadows of some ferns on the floor of a greenhouse, I saw tigers, pistons, bison, tides and armies, I saw all the ants there are on earth, I saw a Persian astrolabe, I saw in a desk drawer (and the handwriting made me tremble) obscene, unbelievable, precise letters that Beatriz had written to Carlos Argentino, I saw a beloved monument in Chacarita, I saw the atrocious relic of what had deliciously been Beatriz Viterbo, I saw the circulation of my own dark blood, I saw the gears of love and the alteration of death, I saw the Aleph, from every point, I saw in the Aleph the earth, and in the earth the Aleph once more and in the Aleph the earth, I saw my face and my entrails, I saw your face, and I felt dizzy and I wept, because my eyes had seen that secret and conjectural object whose name men usurp, but which no man has ever looked upon: the inconceivable universe."
Jorge Luis Borges, "The Aleph" (1945)
Nobody graduates from a degree seeing the entire universe. But a university can teach people to look from more than one point, to not mistake their own little plot for the whole, and to take responsibility for what gets decided with that view. UBA did it before, with an 18-meter computer and an institute that lasted five years. This time it's doing it by designing an experiment, a pilot program, within its tradition and with its doors open. We're excited by the reach these ideas are having. We want to put them at the service of new questions and new answers for the present and, above all, for the future: for the education of those who will lead and make decisions in every sphere of the society the University of Buenos Aires is part of.
As the Ramones used to say: Hey! Ho! Let’s Go!
Las notas de 421 no tienen paywall
Y a cada colaborador se le paga por su trabajo. Las dos cosas dependen de los suscriptores.